Home / Our Goodies

Cookies

Our award-winning, premium handmade cookies are the best of the best — made with only high-quality ingredients.

We’ve made absurd amounts of delicious goodies over the years — but don't take our word for it — look for yourself! We wish we could have every one of these babies available all the time too but there are limits to the human body. Luckily, you can snag an ever-changing lineup of amazing goodies and more each week, so come by often!

Apple Cinnamon
$5.50
Not available for now
Nothing like some warm apple pie… But seriously, putting together apple pie and a cinnamon roll smothered in cream cheese frosting is amongst the best decisions ever made.
Banoffee
$5.50
Not available for now
Get your banana fix with a creamy, crunchy, and gooey cookie that throws all those Banoffee pie ingredients in — bananas, crumbled Biscoff cookies, Dulce de leche, generous chunks of Heath bar, topped w/ whipped cream frosting.
Birthday Cake
$5.50
5 available now
Don't you wish you could have your [birthday] cake every day and eat it too? Well, now you can. Birthday Cake Oreos + white chocolate chips + sprinkles + a thick layer of vanilla buttercream = L-O-V-E.
Add to Order
New!
Buckeye Sandwich
$6.00
Not available for now
Our fresh take on the famous "Buckeye"! Two chocolate cookies with @thebuckeyelady specialty buckeyes, chocolate chips, and hot fudge sandwiches our fluffy peanut butter frosting, which is then rolled in our house-made "puppy chow"!
Butterscotch Brownie
$5.50
Not available for now
As if our cookies weren't already ridiculous enough, how about a triple chocolate butterscotch cookie that has a frakkin' brownie stuffed inside of it, then is filled and made pretty with a rose of browned butter buttercream? Yeah? We thought so too!
Caramel Brookie
$5.50
Not available for now
Chocolate cookie mixed with white, dark, and semisweet chocolate chips, chunks of brownies and Milky Way bars, then stuffed with a piece of Little Debbie Devil Cremes, and topped with chocolate chip cookie dough frosting, caramel drizzle, and a decorative Milky Way as the cherry on top. Woah.
Carrot Cake Sandwich
$5.50
Not available for now
(A personal favorite of Tudie herself.) A spiced cookie dough mixed with carrots, raisins, walnuts, candied pecans, and chunks of Stroopwafel, then generously sandwiched with a cinnamon cream cheese frosting and filled with a homemade butterscotch ganache. White chocolate drizzles and cute little sprinkles make it decadent but not too bougie.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
$5.50
4 available now
Peanut butter, Nutella, boom. (You're welcome). That's all we have to say about that.
Add to Order
Classic Chocolate Chip
$5.50
17 available now
Our most popular cookie is a classic so good you really don't need any further description of them, do you? Just look at these babies! (Yeah, they taste just as good as they look.)
Add to Order
Coffee Toffee
$5.50
Not available for now
Coffee + toffee... These two rich flavors meld together to create quite the compliment; perhaps this combination was made for those whose tastes are so much more sophisticated?
Cookie Butter Candy Bar
$5.50
Not available for now
So if you've been aching to eat a cookie full of chopped Butterfinger, injected with cookie butter, and then sprinkled liberally with cinnamon and sugar, this is the one. Just sayin'.
Cookies & Cream
$5.50
Not available for now
There's more than meets the eye with this one: our signature base mixed with chopped Cookies & Cream Twix & Pop Tarts, white chocolate chips, stuffed with creamy Oreo hot fudge, then topped with everyone's favorite Hershey's Cookies 'n' Cream bar. Can't go wrong with all that.
Dark Chocolate Pistachio & Toffee
$5.50
Not available for now
A perfect combination of sweet and salty: dark chocolate and toffee chips get to know each other before growing their inner circle to include their new friend the pistachio and world-renowned flakey sea salt. ::Chef's kiss::
Fluffernutter
$5.50
Not available for now
The epic Fluffernutter! 🥜 Peanut butter chips, mini marshmallows, Peanut Butter cups, Nutterbutters, and then filled to the brim with some sweet mallow fluff and peanut butter again. Enough?
New!
Halloween Candy Bar
$5.50
Not available for now
Boo! Get into the fall spirit early with our Halloween Candy Bar cookie: our delicious base dough is packed with Halloween M&Ms, green "Witch's Brew" marshmallow-creme Kit Kats, white chocolate chips, and then filled up with chocolate ganache!
Irish Cream Coffee
$5.50
Not available for now
Get lucky this St. Patty’s Day with our Irish Cream Coffee cookies—brown butter espresso dough with a trifecta of espresso, chocolate, and toffee chips, filled with an Irish cream liqueur buttercream.
Lemon Bar
$5.50
Not available for now
🍋 Our amazing Lemon Bar cookies are made up of lemon Oreos, white chocolate chips, and stuffed with lemon pound cake, only to be topped with delicious lemon curd and cream cheese frosting!
Lemon Blueberry Cheesecake
$5.50
Not available for now
This bright combo pairs a lemon base with chopped lemon Oreo, white chocolate Kit Kat, then topped with blueberry cream cheese frosting and a drizzle of fresh blueberry sauce!
Oatmeal Cream Pie
$6.00
9 available now
A perfect pair of hearty and rich oatmeal cookies tag-team a healthy dose of cookie butter and a drizzle of caramel, perfectly sandwiching them all together for-ev-ver (or at least until you devour them in one sitting, then hate yourself.)
Add to Order
New!
Oatmeal Scotchie
$5.50
Not available for now
Peanut Butter & Jelly Sandwich
$6.00
Not available for now
It's peanut butter jelly time! Peanut butter jelly time! Now there ya go! There ya go! There ya go! Strawberry buttercream smashed between two peanut butter chip cookies, with a quick hit of peanut butter & strawberry jelly in the middle.
Peanut Butter Cookies & Cream
$5.50
Not available for now
Do you like those chocolate wafer cookies? (You: "Duh.") Do you love peanut butter? (You: "Of course.") So we went ahead and smashed those delicious things together into this delicious thing.
Peppermint Hot Chocolate
$5.50
Not available for now
Ring in the holiday season with the gift of our freshly addictive, hot chocolate cookie sandwich, stuffed with marshmallow buttercream then topped with a beautifully fancy white chocolate drizzle and white chocolate peppermint chunks and holiday sprinkles. Ho—ho—how many is too many to eat in one sitting?!
New!
Pumpkin Cheesecake
$5.50
Not available for now
Fall into fall with our Pumpkin Cheesecake cookie! Pumpkin spiced dough, cinnamon and cream cheese chips, pumpkin pie Kit Kats, then topped off with pumpkin butter and a healthy swirl of spiced cream cheese frosting!
Pumpkin Triple Chocolate
$5.50
Not available for now
Is pumpkin spice a carb? Let fall be in the air any time of the year with these deliciously chocolatey pumpkin cookies—if that's, like, your thing.
Red Velvet
$5.50
3 available now
Looking for a sweet treat for your “Sweetie Pie”, your “Hunny Bun”, your Beau (…or just yourself? 😉) Well, we pinky promise that these Red Velvet cookies will do just the trick!
Add to Order
S’mores
$5.50
Not available for now
First you take the graham, you stick the chocolate on the graham. Then you roast the 'mallow. When the mallow's flaming... you stick it on the chocolate. Then cover it with the other end. Then, you scarf.
Salted Butter Pecan
$5.50
Not available for now
Rich, buttery cookies made with a combo of butterscotch and white chocolate chips, pecans, then topped with a bit of flakey sea salt. Like the ice cream, but better. 😉
Salted Caramel Pretzel
$5.50
Not available for now
Sea salt, caramel. chocolate-covered pretzels... What else did you need us to put in here exactly?
Strawberry Pretzel Cheesecake
$5.50
Not available for now
Like that classic strawberry pretzel dessert we all know and love, but living its best life in cookie form!
Walnut Chocolate Chip
$5.50
Not available for now
A pile of brown butter dough, stuffed with chopped walnuts, then injected full of Nutella and salted to perfection!
White Chocolate Macadamia
$5.50
Not available for now
White Chocolate Peanut Butter Pretzel
$6.00
9 available now
Add to Order
New!
White Chocolate Strawberry Pretzel
$5.50
Not available for now

Emma Pratt

September 11, 2022.

Best breakfast sandwich I've ever had. Cinnamon roll and coffee were great, too. Friendly staff. Highly recommend it.

Megan Denti

September 8, 2022.

We love tudie's! The cookies are amazing and unique and the owner is always incredibly welcoming.

Alana Feasel

September 7, 2022.

The sizes of the treats are absolutely HUGE and they have the taste to back it up. The chocolate chip cookie is delish

Stephanie Brim

September 4, 2022.

Had a delicious blueberry muffin,still warm from the oven. Was heaven. Love this place!

theRuhlMan

August 28, 2022.

We've fallen into a weekly trip here for the family. Everything we've tried has been great!

Susie Walden

August 14, 2022.

Super nice people and delicious cookies!

Susan Trager

August 10, 2022.

I just got the berry pie and the brownie with caramel sauce on it. My favorite is the berry pie. Delicious. Highly recommend . Prices are reasonable also.

Melissa M

July 24, 2022.

This is a must-try bakery! Tudies gives crumble a run for the money.

Tudie's Cookies & Sweets

Cookies

What do you want to see?

Apple Cinnamon

Banoffee

Birthday Cake

Buckeye Sandwich

Butterscotch Brownie

Caramel Brookie

Carrot Cake Sandwich

Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie

Classic Chocolate Chip

Coffee Toffee

Cookie Butter Candy Bar

Cookies & Cream

Dark Chocolate Pistachio & Toffee

Fluffernutter

Halloween Candy Bar

Irish Cream Coffee

Lemon Bar

Lemon Blueberry Cheesecake

Oatmeal Cream Pie

Oatmeal Scotchie

Peanut Butter & Jelly Sandwich

Peanut Butter Cookies & Cream

Peppermint Hot Chocolate

Pumpkin Cheesecake

Pumpkin Triple Chocolate

Red Velvet

S’mores

Salted Butter Pecan

Salted Caramel Pretzel

Strawberry Pretzel Cheesecake

Walnut Chocolate Chip

White Chocolate Macadamia

White Chocolate Peanut Butter Pretzel

White Chocolate Strawberry Pretzel

Visit us!