Ordering
Ugh, darn! Ordering is temporarily unavailable. 🥺 In the meantime, check out our sweets & plan ahead for when ordering opens up again, which should be very soon!
All products are available for local pickup in the Columbus, Ohio area only.
-
Banoffee Pie
$5 / for Single
$15 / for 3-Pack
$30 / for Half DozenGet your banana fix with a creamy, crunchy, and gooey cookie that throws all those Banoffee Pie ingredients in — bananas, crumbled Biscoff cookies, Dulce de Leche, generous chunks of Heath bar, topped w/ whipped cream frosting.
-
Birthday Cake
$5 / for Single
$15 / for 3-Pack
$30 / for Half DozenDon’t you wish you could have your [birthday] cake every day and eat it too? Well, now you can. Birthday Cake Oreos + white chocolate chips + sprinkles + a thick layer of vanilla buttercream = L-O-V-E.
-
Caramel Brookie
$5 / for Single
$15 / for 3-Pack
$30 / for Half DozenChocolate cookie mixed with white, dark, and semisweet chocolate chips, chunks of brownies and Milky Way bars, then stuffed with a piece of Little Debbie Devil Cremes, and topped with chocolate chip cookie dough frosting, caramel drizzle, and a decorative Milky Way as the cherry on top. Wow.
-
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
$5 / for Single
$15 / for 3-Pack
$30 / for Half DozenPeanut butter, Nutella, boom. You’re welcome. That’s all I have to say about that.
-
Classic Chocolate Chip
$5 / for 2-Pack
$15 / for Half Dozen
$30 / for Baker's DozenOur classic chocolate chip cookies are so good we don’t need to describe them any further, do we?
-
Cookie Butter Candy Bar
$5 / for Single
$15 / for 3-Pack
$30 / for Half DozenSo if you’ve been aching to eat a cookie full of chopped Butterfinger, injected with cookie butter, and then sprinkled liberally with cinnamon and sugar, this is the one. Just sayin’.
-
Dark Chocolate, Pistachio, & Toffee
$5 / for 2-Pack
$15 / for Half Dozen
$30 / for Baker's DozenA perfect combination of sweet and salty: dark chocolate and toffee chips get to know each other before growing their inner circle to include their new friend the pistachio and world-renowned flakey sea salt. ::Chef’s kiss::
-
Lemon Blueberry Cheesecake
$5 / for Single
$15 / for 3-Pack
$30 / for Half DozenWelcome spring into your home with this bright combo, pairing a lemon base with chopped lemon Oreo, white chocolate Kit Kat, then topped with blueberry cream cheese frosting and a drizzle of fresh blueberry sauce!
-
Oatmeal Cream Pie with Cookie Butter Buttercream
$5 / for Single
$15 / for 3-Pack
$30 / for Half DozenA perfect pair of hearty and rich oatmeal cookies tag-team a healthy dose of cookie butter and a drizzle of caramel, perfectly sandwiching them all together for-ev-ver (or at least until you devour them in one sitting, then hate yourself.)
-
Peanut Butter & Jelly Sandwich
$5 / for Single
$15 / for 3-Pack
$30 / for Half DozenIt’s peanut butter jelly time! Peanut butter jelly time! Now there ya go! There ya go! There ya go! Strawberry buttercream smashed between two peanut butter chip cookies, with a quick hit of peanut butter & strawberry jelly in the middle.
-
S’mores
$5 / for Single
$15 / for 3-Pack
$30 / for Half DozenFirst you take the graham, you stick the chocolate on the graham. Then you roast the ‘mallow. When the mallow’s flaming… you stick it on the chocolate. Then cover it with the other end. Then, you scarf.
-
Salted Butter Pecan
$5 / for Single
$15 / for 3-Pack
$30 / for Half DozenRich, buttery cookies made with a combo of butterscotch and white chocolate chips, pecans, then topped with a bit of flakey sea salt. Like the ice cream, but better. 😉
-
Salted Caramel Pretzel
$5 / for Single
$15 / for 3-Pack
$30 / for Half DozenSea salt, caramel. chocolate-covered pretzels. What else did you need us to put in here exactly?
